Flashcards Studio

During a House inquiry in aid of legislation into alleged overpricing in awarding a nationwide water utility franchise, the committee subpoenas the Chief Financial Officer of the private concessionaire to testify and to produce emails, the franchise contract, board minutes, and bid communications. The CFO refuses, claiming that the materials contain sensitive trade secrets and personal data of third parties. The committee contends that the subpoena is authorized by the Constitution’s power to conduct inquiries in aid of legislation and by the committee’s rules. (a) Identify the controlling doctrine governing legislative inquiries and the authority for subpoena power. (b) Distinguish this doctrine from related concepts and explain the limits on the subpoena power. (c) Apply the doctrine to these facts and decide whether the subpoena should be sustained and what remedies are available if the private party refuses.