Beta

Flashcards Studio

Practice bar questions and get clear AI feedback on every answer.

Study Settings View Stats

Topic

Question Type

Essay Multiple Choice

Question Source

All Jurisprudence based

0 tracked cards Criminal Law

In a city jail, Detective A, acting in official capacity, interrogates detainee B, a 28-year-old suspect in a homicide case. For 48 hours, A deprives B of sleep, withholds water for 20 hours, confines him in a small bare cell, and subjects him to periodic short electric shocks to his limbs to coerce a confession. The acts occur inside the jail; A knows of and approves the actions. (a) Under Republic Act No. 9745 (Anti-Torture Act), has Detective A committed torture? Identify the essential elements and apply them to these facts. (b) Distinguish this conduct from ordinary physical injuries or grave threats under the Revised Penal Code. (c) If torture is established, who may be liable and what penalties apply under RA 9745? Include discussion of possible liability of a superior or the State if applicable.

Choose the Best Answer

Yes; the immediate superior who ordered, tolerated, or knew of and approved the acts may be liable for torture, and the State may be liable for damages under applicable law due to vicarious liability for acts of subordinates. Yes; the essential elements of torture under RA 9745 are satisfied: (1) infliction of severe physical or mental pain, (2) by a person in official capacity, (3) during custody/interrogation, (4) for purposes such as obtaining information or confessions or punishment/intimidation, and (5) with the intent or knowledge that such acts will elicit a confession or coercion. Here, 48 hours without sleep, water deprivation, confinement in a bare cell, and periodic electric shocks clearly inflict severe mental and physical pain to coerce a confession in custody. No; it constitutes ordinary physical injuries under the Revised Penal Code because there is no evidence of lasting physical harm or the required element of severe mental pain. No; RA 9745 requires actual physical injury or death for liability, so acts like sleep deprivation and confinement used to coerce confession do not fall under torture.

Load another random question

Your Progress

No data Retention

Tracked Cards: 0
Accuracy: No data
Retained: 0

View Detailed Analytics

Difficulty Breakdown

Answer flashcards to build a real score-based difficulty breakdown.

Current Streak 0 Days

Start a streak with this card.

Suggested Decks

View All

Leech Cards

Review

No recent weak flashcards in your saved workbook.

More

Flashcards Studio

Question

Choose the Best Answer

Hello